Talking About Mystical Logic Scientifically with Ryu Hasan
Mystical Logic Scientifically with Ryu Hasan
Why "Mystical Logic" Is Still Worth Talking About
A child falls ill and the family blames a curse. A business struggles and someone suggests the office has "bad energy." A lucky number gets picked for a wedding date, a car plate or a house. These habits are so common that we rarely stop to ask where they come from.
Indonesians have a name for this way of thinking: logika mistika, or mystical logic. It means explaining events through hidden, supernatural forces instead of causes we can observe and test.
Dr. Ryu Hasan, the Indonesian neurosurgeon known for his frank, science-first conversations, often talks about this mindset. His angle is not to mock people who hold these beliefs. Instead, he asks a more useful question: why does the human brain find mystical explanations so convincing, and what changes when we look at the same events scientifically?
Where the Term Comes From
The phrase logika mistika is closely tied to Tan Malaka, the Indonesian independence figure and thinker. In his book Madilog (short for Materialism, Dialectics, Logic), written in the early 1940s, he argued that a nation trapped in mystical thinking would struggle to move forward.
His point was practical. If people believe that harvests, illness and poverty are controlled by spirits or fate, they look for solutions in rituals rather than in irrigation, medicine or education. Changing how people reason, he believed, was part of building a modern, independent nation.
Decades later, the idea still resonates. Ryu Hasan's conversations bring the same concern into today's world, but with a new tool Tan Malaka did not have: modern neuroscience, which shows why mystical logic feels so natural to us.
Why the Brain Loves Mystical Explanations
As a brain specialist, Ryu Hasan tends to start from biology. Mystical thinking is not a sign of stupidity. It is a side effect of how the human brain evolved to survive.
The brain hates uncertainty. Not knowing why something happened feels uncomfortable. Any explanation, even a supernatural one, brings relief faster than "we don't know yet."
We see patterns everywhere. The brain links events that happen close together. Wear a certain shirt and win a match twice, and it starts to feel like a lucky shirt.
We assume someone is behind events. Our ancestors survived by assuming a rustling bush meant a predator. That same instinct makes us imagine spirits, curses or hidden intentions behind misfortune.
We remember hits and forget misses. If a fortune teller's prediction comes true once, we tell everyone. The many times it failed quietly disappear from memory. Psychologists call this confirmation bias.
None of these habits make a person foolish. They are shortcuts that once kept us alive. The problem begins when we use them to make important decisions about health, money or other people.
Mystical Logic vs Scientific Thinking: Everyday Examples
The difference is easiest to see side by side. The same event can lead to very different explanations, and very different actions.
Situation
| Mystical logic says
| Scientific thinking asks
|
A child has a high fever for days
| It's a curse or a disturbance from spirits
| What infection could cause this? Has a doctor checked?
|
Sleep paralysis: awake but unable to move, sensing a presence
| A ghost is sitting on your chest
| The brain woke up before the body's sleep paralysis switched off
|
A shop has few customers
| The location has bad luck
| How are the price, location, service and promotion?
|
An earthquake strikes
| It's a punishment or a bad omen
| Which fault line moved, and how can buildings be made safer?
|
A "lucky" ritual before an exam
| The ritual brings success
| Did preparation and calm nerves do the real work?
|
The sleep paralysis example is a favorite for anyone who explains the brain. Many cultures have a ghost story for it, while neuroscience treats it as a known glitch in the transition between sleep and waking.
The key difference is not belief versus disbelief. Scientific thinking simply asks for causes that can be checked, and it stays willing to change its answer when new evidence appears.
How to Think More Scientifically, Without Mocking Belief
Thinking scientifically is not about winning arguments or looking down on others. It is a set of simple habits anyone can practice:
Ask "how do we know?" Before accepting an explanation, ask what evidence supports it.
Look for simpler causes first. Illness, stress, poor sleep or bad luck in the statistical sense often explain more than hidden forces.
Count the misses, not just the hits. A charm that "works" once but fails ten times is not working.
Test when you can. Try changing one thing at a time and see what actually makes a difference.
Be willing to say "I don't know yet." An honest gap is better than a confident wrong answer.
Respect people while questioning ideas. Faith, tradition and culture carry meaning for many people. You can question a claim without insulting the person who holds it.
This matters most when the stakes are high. Choosing a lucky wedding date harms no one. Delaying medical treatment for a sick child because of a supposed curse can cost a life.
Final Thoughts: From Fear to Curiosity
Mystical logic often grows from fear of the unknown. Scientific thinking turns that same unknown into a question worth exploring. Tan Malaka saw this shift as essential for a nation's progress, and Ryu Hasan keeps the conversation alive by showing how our own brains shape what we believe.
You don't have to give up your culture or your faith to think more clearly. You only need the courage to ask one more question before accepting the easiest answer.
Have you ever believed a mystical explanation that later turned out to have a simple scientific cause?